Buy a New Car or a Used Car?

Riya is now settled in her job and wants independence in terms of personal mobility. While the option of Cab Aggregrators look feasible enough; she wants to own a machine that she can term as a ‘safer’ mode. Also after years of hard work, who wouldn’t want to flaunt their success? – Owning a car is still seen as a ‘status symbol’.

Now that Riya has decided that she ought to buy a car; a million dollar question revolves around her mind – whether to buy a brand new car or opt for an used one? We at Auto Punditz would want to answer that – A used car purchase would be more sensible. Let us see the reasons why –

  • New Car Depreciation: The moment you drive your new car off the lot, it will depreciate by as much as 11 percent of its value. Every car undergoes depreciation but a used car has an upper hand for the same when compared to a new car. It depreciates at a slower rate when compared to a brand new car. Have a look at the Depreciation Chart for better understanding:


As seen above, Depreciation of a vehicle is at its peak during the first three years of purchase. But when you are buying a used car, you will obviously purchase it at a price which has already gone under major depreciation.


  • Price of the Used Car: Buying a used car will not only be a much cheaper affair, but would also allow one to explore the higher segments. Ex: A friend of mine recently bought a top end Scorpio AT (2010 model with 52kms  on the odo) at a price of Rs.7 Lakh – while he couldn’t have sneaked a top end NEW Maruti Swift Diesel at the same price! Also note that the Top End NEW Scorpio would currently cost over Rs.15 Lakh.
  • Better Condition & Reliability: With time, today’s generation cars sustain for a longer period of time. The improved technology has enhanced the durability factor of the vehicles and thus the age of these machines has increased. Hence, buying a used car is much tension-free decision now.
  • Organised Sellers: Earlier the market was dominated by Brokers and lacked trust-worthiness. However, many OEMs and Organised players have jumped into the bandwagon of selling ‘CERTIFIED’ Used Cars. The experience promised is same as buying a new car and the same is backed with easy serviceability.
  • Cheaper Insurance: No matter the age of your car, insurance will be a concern. Rates will almost always be lower for used cars than new cars, but regardless, keeping coverage costs low is a good savings strategy.

Otherwise, The factors which will incline you towards New Car are:

  • It’s NEW, duh! – A new car hasn’t been in any accidents, hasn’t been mistreated by unknown evildoers, doesn’t smell funny, has seen no wear or tear, and comes with a clean history that includes only being driven off the line, onto a transporter, and then around the dealer’s lot.
  • New Launch – Almost 50% of the Top 10 selling cars today are the ones which have been launched in the past 2 years. Cars have become a fad today and customers are opting for newer models which are better looking and are loaded with latest features. The newer the car, the more modern the geeky tech that’s packed inside. Multimedia and navigation interfaces are constantly evolving and improving, so if you have to have the latest in gadgets (and don’t want to add them yourself post-factory) the selection will be better in the new-car showroom
  • Financing — Banks offer lower financing rates on new vehicles because the vehicles are inherently worth more and have not already been hit by depreciation.
  • Lesser Maintenance cost — Some new cars, mainly those from luxury marques, include free scheduled maintenance for a certain amount of time or mileage. This built-in cost saving should be considered in the final price analysis if applicable.
  • Hassle-free Purchase Experience – Once you’ve chosen a vehicle, or at least the brand you’re interested in, much of the new-car search can be offloaded on the salesperson, who can find the car you ask for. The same search in the used realm requires a lot more legwork on your part—hunting on the internet, visiting multiple private sellers, and driving from used lot to used lot.
Indian Used Car Sales Statistics (v/s new car sales)

In overall, we believe that the Indian Consumer has aligned towards used car purchases and the segment has grown phenomenally well. As on date, used car sales have overtook new car sales and the same is bound to double by 2020. Hence, if you think buying an used car is smart, than you are right!

Top 10 cars of Nov’16

Source: ET

*UVs and Vans are excluded from the list. Also Elite i20 figures do not include i20 active sales numbers (1316 units)

  • 6 out of Top 10 belong from the Maruti stable! Maruti is leaving no stone unturned to sustain Alto in the Numero Uno slot.
  • Only 2 Hyundai’s are seen in the Top 10 table. The month did extract the juice of the Korean major – ‘Demon’itaztion impact is clearly seen. Also did it find difficult to push stock to the dealers as year-end is approaching?
  • Grand i10 emerged as the best seller for Hyundai – With the demise of i10; Grand i10 is carrying a lot of stake ahead. However, a model change is expected soon – so will the numbers decline in Dec’16?
  • Tiago proves to be the comeback vehicle for Tata Motors. Tata Motors regain the 3rd position in the OEM Ranking after quite some time. A surprising month for Tata Motors though – rejig in the management earlier and now the ranking.
  • Kwid is for Renault what Tiago is for Tata. The entry level hatchs are back in the game! Alto, Celerio, Kwid and Tiago proves that even in tough times this segment will survive – Not many blackmoney hoarders would buy an entry level hatch 😉

November 2016 Car Sales – Snapshot

Two big highlights of the Nov’s statistics –

  • Maruti exudes clear dominance with over 50% Market Share (52.2% to be precise)
  • Did we see Tata silently climb up the ladder? Tata Motors is now India’s THIRD biggest car OEM!


Even with ‘Demonitization’ aftermath, India Passenger Car Industry posted a humble growth of 2%. And like always, Maruti led the growth phenomena.